Browse > Peanut & Nut Butters

Best prices on Peanut & Nut Butters

Compare prices and get delivery on 64 brands of peanut nut butters.

Justin's Almond Butter

32 options

from $0.59

per oz

Peanut Butter & Co.

25 options

from $0.11

per oz

RX Nut Butter

27 options

from $0.65

per oz

Jif

20 options

from $0.09

per oz

Skippy Natural

18 options

from $0.14

per oz

Barney Butter

17 options

from $0.69

per oz

Justin's Peanut Butter

17 options

from $0.16

per oz

Peter Pan

20 options

from $0.12

per oz

Skippy

11 options

from $0.12

per oz

Jif Natural

14 options

from $0.12

per oz

PBfit

11 options

from $0.08

per oz

SunButter Organic

8 options

from $0.56

per oz

SunButter Natural

8 options

from $0.33

per oz

SunButter

7 options

from $0.27

per oz

Once Again

12 options

from $0.51

per oz

MaraNatha All Natural No Stir Almond Butter

9 options

from $0.55

per oz

Smucker's Natural

9 options

from $0.16

per oz

Nutella

9 options

from $0.20

per oz

Skippy Reduced Fat

5 options

from $0.14

per oz

Noosh

8 options

from $1.50

per oz

Peanut Butter & Co. Powder

7 options

from $0.74

per oz

Justin's Hazelnut Butter

7 options

from $0.62

per oz

Jif To Go

7 options

from $0.13

per oz

Smucker's Organic

6 options

from $0.22

per oz

PBfit Organic

2 options

from $0.40

per oz

Peter Pan Natural

8 options

from $0.12

per oz

Teddie

5 options

from $0.23

per oz

Laura Scudder's

5 options

from $0.19

per oz

SuperFat

5 options

from $2.33

per oz

Peanut Butter & Co. Easy Squeezy

5 options

from $0.31

per oz

Split Nutrition

4 options

from $1.86

per oz

Jif Reduced Fat

4 options

from $0.09

per oz

Justin's Cashew Butter

4 options

from $1.00

per oz

PBfit Sugar-Free

3 options

from $0.68

per oz

Just Great Stuff

3 options

from $1.31

per oz

SunButter No Sugar Added

3 options

from $0.42

per oz

Jif Whips

3 options

from $0.21

per oz

Simply Jif

3 options

from $0.14

per oz

Jif To Go Natural

3 options

from $0.17

per oz

Peter Pan Simply Ground

2 options

from $0.63

per oz

Barney Butter Powdered

2 options

from $1.00

per oz

Adams

2 options

from $0.16

per oz

Great Value

2 options

from $0.07

per oz

Peanut Butter & Co. Dipping Cups

2 options

from $0.15

per oz

Santa Cruz Organic

4 options

from $0.41

per oz

PB Crave

3 options

from $0.37

per oz

Laura Scudder's Organic

3 options

from $0.31

per oz

Smart Balance

3 options

from $0.22

per oz

Jif Hazelnut Spread

3 options

from $0.20

per oz

Nutella & Go!

4 options

from $0.60

per oz

Peter Pan Whipped

2 options

from $0.21

per oz

Smucker's Goober

2 options

from $0.15

per oz

Jif Omega-3

2 options

from $0.13

per oz

Barney Butter Snack Packs

2 options

from $2.56

per oz

Smucker's Singles

2 options

from $0.30

per oz

MaraNatha Organic Almond Butter

3 options

from $1.51

per oz

SunButter On The Go

3 options

from $0.70

per oz

MaraNatha

1 option

from $0.54

per oz

Reese's

1 option

from $0.49

per oz

MaraNatha Organic No Stir

1 option

from $0.49

per oz

Adams Organic

1 option

from $0.30

per oz

MaraNatha Organic Peanut Butter

1 option

from $0.06

per oz

MaraNatha All Natural Almond Butter

1 option

from $1.00

per oz

Nutella Mini Cups

1 option

from $1.59

per oz